Accounts are open. Buying and bidding switch on when payments go live; slabs marked Example are samples. Create your account

Sell on Midshelf

Sell your slabs to collectors who want them.

Graded PSA, BGS, SGC and CGC cards from $25 to $1,000 sell here without auction-house minimums or eBay's 13.25%. Type a cert number and the card and grade fill in from the grader's registry. Sell at a fixed price with Best Offer, run a live auction, or send the slabs to us.

Create a seller account

Three ways to sell

Buy Now

8%

You set the price. Buyers can pay it or send a Best Offer.

  1. Enter the grader and cert number. The card and grade fill in.
  2. Photograph the front and back. See recent sold prices and set yours.
  3. Accept, decline or counter offers from your Seller Hub.
  4. Ship within 2 business days on our prepaid label. Paid every Friday.

Auction

8%

Let collectors bid. Run it for 15 minutes live or up to 7 days.

  1. Set a starting bid and, if you want, a hidden reserve.
  2. Bidders enter their max; the site bids for them in set steps.
  3. A bid in the last 2 minutes adds 2 minutes, so nobody wins by sniping.
  4. The winner is charged when it closes. You ship, we pay you Friday.

Consign it to us

10–14%

Ship once, free. We photograph, price, sell and ship.

  1. Enter your cert numbers and see your estimated payout.
  2. Print the prepaid, insured label and send one box.
  3. We suggest a price from sold comps. You approve it or set a floor.
  4. Live within 48 hours of arrival. Paid every Friday.

What you'd get

List it yourself

$165.60

fee $14.40

Consign it

$158.40

fee $21.60

Shipping labels are on us: when a slab sells we give you a prepaid label. Payment processing is included in the fee.

Fees

Listing is free either way. The fee comes out only when a slab sells, and it includes payment processing.

List it yourself

Any priceminimum fee $18%

Consign it to us

$25 – $99minimum fee $314%
$100 – $49912%
$500 – $99910%
$1,000 and up8%
Where you sell a $200 slabSeller feeCard minimumExtra costsYour time
Midshelf, list yourself8%NoneNone2 minutes + shipping
Midshelf, consign12%$25None2 minutes
eBay yourself13.25% + $0.40NoneSupplies, shipping, returnsPhotos, listing, packing
ORB consignment15%NoneLocal drop-offLow
PSA Vault on eBay~13%$750 to vaultCard must be vaultedLow
COMC5% + intakeNone$2.50 per graded cardWeeks to list
Auction houses5 – 15%~$1,000Buyer's premium30 – 90 days

Competitor figures from public fee pages and published comparisons, September 2026. Rates change; check before you rely on them.

Questions

Should I list it myself or consign?

List it yourself if you have a few slabs and don't mind a trip to the post office: you keep more at 8%. Consign if you have a stack of cards, want pro photos and pricing, or don't want to ship each sale.

How do auctions work?

You pick a starting bid, an optional hidden reserve and a length from 15 minutes to 7 days. Bidders enter the most they'd pay and the site bids for them one step at a time, so the winner pays one step over the second-highest max. A bid in the final 2 minutes adds 2 minutes. If the reserve isn't met, nothing sells and you can relist or switch to Buy Now.

Can I end an auction early?

Only before the first bid. Once someone bids, the auction runs to the end. Bidders plan around the end time.

How does Best Offer work?

On Buy Now listings, buyers can offer at least 60% of your price. You accept, decline or counter within 48 hours. An accepted offer charges the buyer right away and becomes an order like any other sale.

What are the rules for sellers?

Ship within 2 business days using the label we provide, in a bubble sleeve and a box or rigid mailer. The card must match its cert number and photos. Late or wrong shipments add a strike; three strikes in 90 days pauses listing.

Why only graded cards?

A graded slab has a cert number anyone can look up. We match every listing to the grader's registry, which stops fakes and condition disputes before they start.

Which graders do you accept?

PSA, BGS, SGC and CGC. Cracked or tampered slabs can't be listed or consigned.

New seller limits?

For your first 30 days, each slab can be listed up to $500 and you can have 25 listings at once. Our team reviews each one before it goes live.

When do I get paid?

Every Friday by ACH or PayPal, for sales where the buyer has the card and the 3-day return window has closed. There's no minimum payout.

Are consigned cards insured?

Yes, from the carrier's first scan until they sell or come back to you, at your approved list price.

Can I get consigned cards back?

Anytime. Ask from your Seller Hub and we ship it back. Returns are free after 90 days listed; before that it's $8 per shipment.

Ready when you are

It takes about two minutes to list your first slab.

Create a seller account